Is This ABA Provider Any Good? Five Things the Records Reveal

Is this ABA provider any good? Five things the records reveal – Bassos Consulting Group

Attorneys and families ask me this question more than you’d think. A family law attorney wants to know whether the provider one parent chose is competent. A healthcare attorney is deciding whether a denied claim was for care that met the standard, and a family wants to understand what is being billed and why their child isn’t making gains. The answer is almost always in the records already in the file, if you know what to look for. Here are the five things I check first.

Whether the treatment plan is built on a current assessment

A proper ABA treatment plan starts with an assessment of the person’s skills and behavior, repeated at least every six months. Look at the date of the assessment the plan cites and compare it to the date of the plan. If a two-year-old assessment is still driving the goals, the plan is based on a child who has since changed a great deal. Then look at whether the goals actually come from the assessment. A plan that lists twenty generic goals that could apply to any child is a template, not a treatment plan, and it usually means nobody is looking closely at this particular child.

Whether the data goes up, down or nowhere

Every goal in an ABA plan should have a graph. Ask for the graphs, not the summaries. A competent program shows data that changes over time, with notes when the team changed something in response. What you are looking for is the opposite: a flat line for months with no change in approach. Flat data by itself does not mean malpractice; some skills take a long time. Flat data with no documented response to it is the problem, because the whole method depends on adjusting treatment when the data says it is not working. If the progress reports say “continuing to make progress” while the graphs say nothing is moving, the reports are not describing the data.

How much supervision the child actually received

ABA is delivered mostly by technicians and the standard requires a Board Certified Behavior Analyst to supervise that work, typically for a set percentage of the treatment hours every month. The session notes show who was in the room and for how long. Add up the supervisor’s hours against the technician’s hours. A program that bills forty hours a week of direct therapy and shows one supervision visit a month is not being supervised in any real sense, and in my experience that is where most of the harm starts. Also check whether the supervisor’s notes describe anything specific. “Observed session, provided feedback” repeated every month is not supervision.

Whether the parents and caregivers were trained and whether they showed up

Caregiver training is part of the standard of care, not an extra. The plan should include caregiver goals and the records should show scheduled sessions, who attended and what was practiced. A provider who never scheduled parent training was not doing the job. A parent who was offered training and did not come is a different fact and in a time-sharing case it is often the most important one in the file, because consistency between home and treatment is what makes the treatment hold.

What the behavior plan says about restraint and crisis

If the child has aggression, self-injury or elopement, there should be a behavior intervention plan that names the function of the behavior, the replacement skills being taught and exactly what staff do in a crisis. Read the crisis section carefully. A good plan describes de-escalation first and lists any physical intervention as a last resort with a reporting requirement. A plan that jumps straight to holds, or that does not address the behavior at all while incident reports pile up, tells you the program is managing the child rather than treating the child. Compare the incident reports to the plan. If the same behavior keeps happening and the plan never changes, the records have already answered your question.

What this looks like in a case

None of these five things requires a clinical background to spot once you know where they are. What they do not tell you is whether the gaps matter for this child, and that is where an expert comes in. A missed reassessment on a child who is doing well is a paperwork problem. The same gap on a child whose behavior is escalating is a standard-of-care problem. My job is to tie what the records show to what the child needed and to say, in plain language, whether the provider met the standard.

If you’re looking at an ABA provider’s records, whether for a family law, healthcare or malpractice matter or for your own child, get in touch and I can tell you quickly whether there’s something there.

Have a case that needs a behavioral expert?

Jamie Bassos, MS, BCBA, LBA, ACC provides evaluations, record review, and expert testimony in legal matters involving autism and behavioral health. Florida and national cases.